REF2014, the latest round of research assessment in the UK, was completed late in 2014.

This micro-site contains the results of an analysis of the REF results for REF Sub-panel 11 – Computer Science and Informatics, comparing the REF scores with citation-based scores.

The main output of REF is an institution-by-institution research quality profile within different disciplines, However, The Computer Science and Informatics sub-panel also published profiles for sub-areas of computing, which are, or have the potential, to influence decision making in computing departments

The citation-based analysis suggests that, despite every effort to ensure fairness, substantial latent bias has emerged between these sub-areas. Not only does this mean that the REF computing sub-area profiles are misleading, but this may also have affected textual feedback to departments, funding to institutions and possibly gender neutrality.

Draft report (v2, 9th May 2015): On REF and citations – how much can we read about sub-areas of computing?

Summary paper (draft v2, 9th May 2015): Citations and Sub-Area Bias in the UK Research Assessment Process

Note: The site author, Alan Dix, was a member of REF 2014 sub-panel 11 “Computer Science and Informatics”, and as such is bound by confidentiality. The analysis is therefore based solely on public domain data and processes, as described in the data section.

45 thoughts on “about

  1. Can you work out how many outputs are co-authored by PHD students? we’re interested in possibly using REF based evidence to argue that the EPSRC should revert to allowing CS PhDs to be funded in projects, not just in the narrow, and sometimes compromised (e.g. gchq captured) CDT programmes.
    I mean every other funding agency in the world (NSF, CNRS, DFG etc etc) funds project phds….but we’d like to have uk specific data to support argument…

  2. I can;t think of an easy way other than spidering the Google scholar pages and then mining individual institution pages – I seem to recall that this kind of thing was a (the?) major demonstrator for the Sem Web IRC, but like so much research, once the project ended … 🙁

    I’d like to get female authorship as well, but have the same problem.

  3. You can download any of the provided casinos above without any problems. If you download the casino app, it will position like a regular replication of the out-and-out site from the mobile version. Unfortunately, all the apps you download choice contrariwise trade on Android. Download casino in 1 click from the schedule, these are the most advanced mechanical applications.

    The best casino apps for Android
    The can of worms is that finding Android apps and downloading them can be iffy, as Google doesn’t sanction real folding money Android casinos to be placed in the Flirt Store.

    Download casino app
    But don’t worry, there is a uncontrived dissolving, you can download the casino app from casinoapk2.xyz.

    As so multitudinous users attired in b be committed to been asking around casino gaming on their Android phones or tablets. We dug around a iota to learn you the best casino apps gift the selfsame real well-heeled experience.

    The most celebrated 1win, download 1win.

    Reviewers validate each application against security to insure confidence in;
    We inclination relieve you rouse real lolly gambling apps with the a-one Android apps;
    The casinos tender the best choice of games.
    Download Sincere On easy street Casino
    It is not always easy as pie to download verifiable change casinos, even on more public smartphones like Samsung Galaxy, HTC Complete or Sony Xperia. So if you want to download the app to away folding money, decipher all below.

    Our crew found the leading casinos contribution trait gambling for your device and ran an uptight 25-step verification operation for them.

    On this epoch you will-power on an relevancy for Android:

    Allowed Promotions – We recollect how much players hanker after to take advantage of the bonuses, so we made unwavering that our featured sites tender exclusive deals for Android.
    Variety of games. Crummy exquisite is a important minus. We just recommend the app, the diversion portfolio is elephantine and varied.
    Deposits – You be in want of as hardly restrictions as on when it comes to depositing and withdrawing filthy lucre to your casino app account. We make steady that all apps we vouch for allow a wide variety of payment methods.
    Fast payouts. All applications proposal fast payments with authentic money, credited to the account in a few hours.
    Motorized Compatibility – Around Apps Anywhere.
    Customer Bear – To be featured on the Featured Record, we call for online casinos to provide sweeping and responsive client service.
    Advantages of an online app for Android
    Extensive video graphics and usability in Android apps.
    Circumstance the unvaried marvellous PC experience.
    Excitable access from the application.
    Casino apps – looking since the best
    We stay and download casino apps to ensure they convene enormous standards. The criteria habituated to to selected a casino app are good as stringent as the criteria utilized to rate a PC casino. Each application has:

    Highest standing graphics;
    Untroubled loading and playing epoch;
    Lustful payouts.

  4. [url=http://finasteride.quest/]finasteride prescription online[/url] [url=http://discountviagra.online/]viagra generic india[/url] [url=http://costofviagra.quest/]viagra without rx[/url] [url=http://trazodone.quest/]trazodone hydrochloride 100 mg[/url] [url=http://acyclovir.monster/]acyclovir tablets[/url] [url=http://ivermectinktab.online/]ivermectin[/url] [url=http://buyingviagra.quest/]can you purchase viagra online[/url] [url=http://disulfiram.quest/]best online no prescription antabuse[/url] [url=http://doxycycline.monster/]medicine doxycycline 100mg[/url] [url=http://strattera.monster/]buy strattera canada[/url]

  5. You actually make it appear so easy together with your presentation but I find this topic to be really one thing which I believe I’d never understand. It kind of feels too complex and extremely vast for me. I’m looking ahead in your subsequent post, I will try to get the hang of it!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *